Unlock the Pros & Cons of Earn‑Outs: 7 Key Insights from Business Brokers for U.S. Sellers & Buyers
What Is an Earn‑Out?
An earn‑out is a contractual arrangement in which a portion of the purchase price is contingent upon the future performance of the business. It usually covers revenue, EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization), or other KPIs like customer retention or product launches.
Bridging the valuation gap:
Imagine a seller thinks their company is worth $5M and the buyer only sees $4M value today. With an earn‑out, the buyer offers $4M upfront and promises the extra if goals are met. That way, both sides stay confident in closing the deal.
Why Earn‑Outs Matter in U.S. Business Sales
U.S. Market Trends & Economic Context
In the U.S., mid‑market transactions often use earn‑outs—particularly in uncertain sectors such as tech, health services, or software. Buyers may be wary about paying a premium upfront, while sellers want to capture future growth potential in an uncertain economic climate.
Typical Earn‑Out Durations in the U.S.
Most earn‑outs run 1–3 years, though some extend to 5 years for long‑term projects or growth plans. Often they represent 10%–25% of the total purchase price; in high‑growth or high‑risk deals, that number may rise to 50% or more.
Top Advantages of Using an Earn‑Out
Higher Potential Sale Price for Sellers
If your business is projected to grow, an earn‑out can unlock extra upside that buyers weren’t willing to pay upfront. Sellers confident in their ability to hit goals can typically negotiate a better total package than a lump‑sum deal.
Risk Mitigation for Buyers
Buyers pay less initially and only release further payments if targets are met. If the business underperforms, the buyer avoids overpaying. This protects them from optimistic seller projections or external economic downturns..
Alignment of Incentives Between Parties
Because earn‑out payments depend on performance, sellers (or retained key employees) remain motivated to help ensure the business succeeds. It improves transition stability and relieves buyer worry about cultural or operational disconnects post‑closing.
Tax Deferral and Cash Flow Benefits
Earn‑outs spread a seller’s income over multiple years, which may defer tax burdens (e.g. capital gains) and smooth personal financial planning. Buyers also benefit from staggered outflows, preserving liquidity post-closing.
Common Disadvantages of Earn‑Outs
Uncertainty and Lower Payout Risk for Sellers
If performance targets aren’t met, sellers may receive significantly less than expected—sometimes nothing beyond the upfront payment. That uncertainty can be a major downside, especially in volatile markets or sectors.
Potential for Manipulation or Disputes
Earn‑outs often hinge on accounting or subjective criteria. Buyers controlling books or operations may influence results, for example by shifting expenses to lower EBITDA. If terms aren’t airtight, disputes or litigation may follow.
Loss of Control and Ongoing Involvement
Sellers may have to stay involved to help meet goals—sometimes under new management. But if they exit too early or don’t remain active, they may have little influence over results, risking unrealized earn‑out compensation.
Administrative Complexity and Legal Costs
Structuring, monitoring, and verifying earn‑outs involves high legal and financial advisory costs. Reporting, separate accounting, and dispute-resolution mechanisms must be built into the agreement, creating complexity many simple deals don’t require.
Structuring an Earn‑Out Effectively
Choosing the Right Metric & Period
Decide whether revenue, EBITDA or non‑financial KPIs make sense. Sellers often favor revenue (easier to hit, harder to manipulate), buyers favor EBITDA for profitability focus. Define targets, thresholds, and whether payments are binary or graduated.
Clarity on Accounting Principles
Agree on GAAP or normalized accounting rules. Specify policies for adjustments, capital expenditures, or overhead allocation. This prevents “creative” bookkeeping that reduces earn‑out payouts.
Escrow, Caps & Multipliers
Protect sellers by negotiating escrow of contingent funds or caps on maximum payout. Multipliers can reward outperformance—e.g., 5× excess EBITDA above target—but both parties must understand implications clearly.
“Good Leaver” and Seller Involvement Clauses
Define a seller’s post‑closing role, tenure, and conditions under which they can leave without forfeiting earn‑out. Include clauses addressing removal, termination, or early exit scenarios to avoid disputes.
Real‑Life Example: Bridging the Gap
Hypothetical U.S. Small Business Sale
Let’s say Jane owns a tech services firm she values at $3M based on projected new contracts. Buyer offers $2.5M cash plus a possible additional $0.5M based on hitting EBITDA targets over the next two years. Jane stays on as CEO during that period to help meet goals and qualifies for the full earn‑out. That setup helps close the valuation gap, builds trust between parties, and ensures the seller is rewarded for their continued contribution.
Lessons from High‑Profile Deals
Though we couldn’t view your requested video directly, large corporate transactions—like EA’s acquisition of PopCap—often include multi‑year earn‑outs tied to specific earnings milestones. Such deals highlight how well‑structured terms can align interests and effectively bridge valuation gaps without overpaying upfront.
When Earn‑Outs Are a Smart Choice—and When to Avoid Them
Seller Remains in Operation vs. Clean Break
Earn‑outs work best when sellers stay involved and can directly influence performance. If a seller walks away immediately after closing, earning based on performance becomes accidental and riskier.
Industries Where Earn‑Outs Are More Common
Typical earn‑out sectors in the U.S. include tech, professional services, medical practices, specialized manufacturing, and startups—any business where future growth is expected and hard to value precisely.
Alternatives: Holdbacks & Seller‑Financing
If earn‑out terms seem too risky, sellers and buyers may prefer a holdback (money held for warranty or indemnity periods) or seller financing (loan over time). These provide partial deferred payment without tying strictly to performance.
Conclusion & Next Steps
Earn‑outs can be a powerful tool for business brokers, sellers, and buyers in the U.S. when used appropriately. They help bridge valuation gaps, share risk, align incentives, and sometimes provide tax and cash flow advantages. But they also carry uncertainty, complexity, and potential for disputes.
If you're considering how to sell your business or buy one using an earn‑out, talk to our expert team at First Choice Business Brokers Phoenix Northwest. We’ll help you structure terms that work, minimize risk, and maximize outcome.
FAQ
1. How long does a typical earn‑out period last?
Most earn‑outs in the U.S. run 1–3 years, though short or longer periods (up to five years) may apply in specific circumstances.
2. What metrics are commonly used?
Revenue, EBITDA, net income, gross profit or specific KPIs (e.g. customer retention, product launch milestones).
3. What percentage of the sale price is often deferred?
Typically 10‑25%, though high‑growth or riskier deals may defer up to 50%.
4. How are earn‑outs taxed?
Earn‑out payments are taxed when received. Depending on structure, they may be treated as capital gains or ordinary income—consult a tax advisor.
5. Can buyers manipulate results?
Yes—if accounting policies and oversight aren’t clearly defined, buyers might shift expenses or overhead to reduce earn‑out payouts. Clear definitions are key.
6. What if buyer fires seller early?
Contracts should include “good leaver/bad leaver” clauses and accelerated payment triggers if termination is without cause.
7. Are earn‑outs legally risky?
They’re one of the most litigated provisions in M&A. Poorly drafted terms often lead to disputes—expert legal guidance is essential.
Get in Touch:
First Choice Business Brokerage Phoenix
📍 21640 N 19th Ave Suite C9, Phoenix, AZ 85027
📞 (623) 888-6190
Recent articles for you
